DR. AMBEDKAR AND THE HINDU CODE BILL 859
now, we have certain principles in our present law which are the basis of the common Civil Code, like the Sarda Act, Majority Act, etc.
Reference was made to articles 25 and 15 of the Constitution Act and some of the provisions in article 25 were even ridiculed. My hon. friend Mr. Nazuriddin Ahmad said that he cannot make anything out of the words “Subject to public order, morality and health” and that they were meaningless. They are not meaningless. They have not full meaning; not only full meaning, but are of very great significance. He seems to have failed to realise the significance of articles 25 and 15. It was said that under article 15, there shall be no discrimination, and that therefore, we cannot have a Hindu Code, a Muslim Code and other Codes. My humble submission is this. Although I would very much like to have one Civil Code for the whole country. I submit that it is not inconsistent with the provisions of the Constitution Act to have a Hindu Code, a Muslim Code and other Codes. I am very sorry to say that I have heard my hon. friends who are in favour of the Hindu Code Bill say that so far as the provisions of Articles 15 and 25 of the Constitution Act are concerned the provisions of the Hindu Code Bill are not consistent. For instance. I am very sorry to submit that I have heard even from the author of the Hindu Code Bill to say that so far as the Constitution is concerned, there can be no discrimination between brothers and sisters, between a male and a female so far as the Hindu Code is concerned.
Dr. Ambedkar : Only on grounds of sex.
Pandit Thakur Das Bhargava : I am coming to that. That is one proposition that has been put forward that on grounds of sex there cannot be any discrimination and article 15 of the Constitution will stand in our way. The other gentlemen, who are opposed to the Hindu Code, also rely on articles 15 and 25 and say that there can be no discrimination. May I humbly ask the Hon. Dr. Ambedkar, if there could be no discrimination on the ground of sex, why he has got so many provosions in the Hindu Code itself which discriminate between the sexes……..
Dr. Ambedkar : There is no provision which discriminates only on the ground of sex.
Pandit Thakur Das Bhargava : This provision of one-fourth for a married daughter and one-half for the unmarried daughter ; why is there a different succession if a man dies and a different one if a woman dies ?