27. Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Bill - Page 284

PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES 267

operation of commissions issued by foreign courts is also not provided for by our present Civil Procedure Code. In order to provide for these matters, there are introduced in this amending Bill clauses 6, 8, 9 and 11 which deal with them. They are by themselves so self-explanatory that I do not think that any observations of mine are necessary to make hon. members understand what is the purport of these new clauses.

The most important clause, of course, is clause 12 and it is with regard to it that I propose to offer some remarks. As will be observed, clause 12 substitutes sections 83, 85, 86,

87 and 87B. These sections deal with suits by aliens, by or against foreign Rulers, Ambassadors and Envoys. Now, the only sections in which certain changes have been made are

86 and 87B. So far as section 86 is concerned, it is really the old section 86 with some minor changes. The one change that is proposed to be made in section 86 is in sub-clause

(2) (d). It deals with the waiving of a privilege given to the foreign Rulers, namely, that they shall be sued only under certain conditions and subject to the satisfaction of certain procedural rules. The question that has been raised is whether any such person covered by the provisions of section 86 can waive this privilege or whether, notwithstanding the fact that he is prepared to waive such privilege, nonetheless the statutory provision should be gone through. Some courts in India have held that this being a statutory privilege of a procedural character, it is not open to the party to waive it and that a person who wants to sue should follow the particular procedure. Now, it does not seem very right or correct that a person who has been given a privilege should be debarred from taking the benefit of that privilege if he thinks that he does not need or does not want the benefit of that privilege. In order, therefore, to set this matter right, this provision has been introduced which expressly says that a person who has been granted this privilege may waive it if he so desires.

The second clause in section 86 which makes a change and to which I wish to draw the attention of the House is subclause (4)(b). We have added to the old categories of privileged persons one more category, namely, the category of a High Commissioner stationed in India. The position of a High