33. Constitution (First Amendment) Bill - Page 376

PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES 359

Dr. Ambedkar: Now I come to articles 341 and 342. As the House knows, to-day the power of issuing scheduled castes and the scheduled tribes order so far as part A and Part B States are concerned is given only to the President while the power to issue such orders with regard to Part C States is given to Parliament. That position is now being altered and the power is given to President even to make an order with regard to scheduled castes and scheduled tribes in respect of Part C States also.

Then article 372 invests the President with the power to make adaptation in existing laws in order to bring them in conformity with the provisions of the Constitution and that power is given only for two years. This House will remember on account of the pressure of other business it has not been possible for Government to examine all the existing laws in order to find out how many of them are inconsistent with the provisions of the Constitution. It is therefore felt that the President’s power to make such adaptation in the existing laws in order to bring them in conformity with the Constitution be extended by one more year so that means may be adopted in order to find out which laws are inconsistent and a consolidated order may be issued thereafter.

Shri Kamath: The article also provides that once Parliament is elected under the new Constitution, the President shall not exercise this power.

Dr. Ambedkar: If this article gives the power, then that of course overrides.

Shri Kamath : How can that be ?

Dr. Ambedkar: Then I come to article 376, clause 13. A good deal of objection was taken to this particular clause. It deals with the appointment of persons who are not citizens of India to the posts of Chief Justice and Judge of any High Court. The position is this. Article 217, clause (2) says that a Judge of the High Court must be a citizen of India. Article

376 provides that existing Judges including Judges who were not citizens on the date when the Constitution came into operation shall continue as Judges if they so choose. Now it